Bloodwinter Clan

What are your thoughts on them?

Give them a few weeks to get settled they are a new guild, give um a while to get stable before invited into the alliance.

gotta agree with orm on this one they just started thier guild. let's see what they can do

They are making a alliance decision end of week.

So I need a yay or no.

So far I have 2 yay's and 2 no's.

i would have to say yes then because it would be a waist for them to join another alliance and turn out to be a killer guild and we would kick ourselves in the ass for not taking the opportunity with them

I would vote yes. They may be small, but they have a lot of active characters, and they've done well in rvr in the past week. Besides, small is good....

Karbide/Colefury/Fatn was bought from an ex-guildie(that is not necessarily bad), but I would say let them play for a week or 2 first. If they get into another alliance and they like to RVR then they will soon want to join BWCa. I say keep the prestige and more people will want to join. I will not flame people, but I would say some of these people should be watched more, and invited to some alliance events. Who cares if they are active and run around in the emain zerg. NN was watched and critiqued before we were on and I say keep those standards. Do not invite someone b/c they "might" be good. I would rather be in a small, but good alliance. Than in a HUGE alliance that everyone is allowed to be in(hence, leaving mytha). My vote is "No" for now....

of who?.. don't even know them so its a no for me..

pesonally i prefer inviting guilds who you want to stay, not inviting guilds who you don't know just because they might be good and then kick them later if they aren't.

I agree with Metsuri here. So if we have to decide it now, I vote against letting them join.

We will still be strong without them, we arn't in a "need" of guilds, if they want to be apart of the bwc family they can wait a few weeks to see how they preform and if they are good people, do we know anything about them cept that they are a new rvr guild? I dont want to see another desolate or infortis, i want people who are here for the long hall.

Orms change your sig bro.

I vote wait and see as well. Dont know them well enough to say they belong with us. If they know whats good for them they will want to prove to us they are worth being in the BWCa.

Thank you.

i'm a little miffed about thier response to the no let's wait answer. Now they claim that they don't know what they are going to do kinda like a high pressure salesman tactic if ya ask me........

Naw, I understand their point completely. Without either a very active guild, or a good /as, it's hard to know when stuff is going on. And the game is alot more fun when stuff is going on.

So they can continue to not know anything, or they can compromise and join Myth /as, which I'd guess they will do. Maybe they'll reapply later after Drutt goes psychopathic again.

It was still the right answer from us though.

BUMP!!!
I grouped with these guys today in emain. They mentioned that they were still looking for a good alliance. I asked if they had applied for BWC (oops). Anyways my point being that i had a lot of fun / got a bunch of RPs. Just thought i would bump this up and see if anyone has any more thoughts / suggestions.